In a previous post, I discussed some of the magical aspects of headwear in Faery. I’m returning to the subject now, with a slightly wider perspective on faeries and their hats.
It’s a common perception today that faeries are likely to be seen wearing hats- and often peculiar looking ones at that. I’ll come to this in more detail shortly, but in preparing this posting I went back to some of the older sources of information to see what they had to say on the subject. It was certainly accepted in previous centuries that the fae would be seen in some kind of hat, cap or bonnet, but that was a great deal less remarkable to people given that headwear was the norm. You’re far less likely to say “oh, he was wearing a hat” if absolutely everyone in your world has their head covered. The result is that some of the statements are fairly prosaic. For example, one Welsh woman who spoke to Evans Wentz said that the tylwyth teg had been seen around the Pentre Ifan cromlech in Ceredigion and that they were small, like children, and wearing red caps (Fairy Faith, 155). Likewise, in McGregor’s Peat Fire Flame there are reports of sith folk from the Highlands in “green broad rimmed hats” or a “red bonnet” (pages 14 & 78); the faeries whose departure from this Middle Earth was seen in Hugh Miller’s Old Red Sandstone sported red caps, and Wirt Sikes mentioned other members of the tylwyth teg in red caps with feathers or “red tripled caps” (British Goblins, 83 & 132). The latter is interesting because of the apparent elaborateness of the items; I’m not sure exactly what’s implied here, but evidently we’re dealing with something that’s a bit unusual when contrasted to day to day human head gear. There’s also a mention of a faery in a cap of gorse blossom (pages 79 & 81); I can’t help but suspect some romanticising influence here, part of the Victorian trend to miniaturise and prettify faery-kind.
In Superstitions of the Highlands & Islands of Scotland, by John Gregorson Campbell, we have some very interesting statements of sith headwear- under the heading ‘Fairy Dresses’ he tells the reader that:
“The Fairies, both Celtic and Teutonic, are dressed in green. In Skye, however, though Fairy women, as elsewhere, are always dressed in that colour, the men wear clothes of any colour like their human neighbours. They are frequently called daoine beaga ruadh, “little red men,” from their clothes having the appearance of being dyed with the lichen called crotal, a common colour of men’s clothes, in the North Hebrides. The coats of Fairy women are shaggy, or ruffled (caiteineach), and their caps curiously fitted or wrinkled. The men are said, but not commonly, to have blue bonnets, and in the song to the murdered Elfin lover, the Elf is said to have a hat bearing ‘a smell of honied apples.’ This is perhaps the only Highland instance of a hat, which is a prominent object in the Teutonic superstition, being ascribed to the Fairies.”
Superstitions (1900), 14
Campbell highlights the notable ‘fanciness’ of the female faes caps, connecting us to those tripled caps in Wales. His mention of the scented hat is fascinating- as well as being unique. He suggests that headwear is unusual in the Highlands, but McGregor has already contradicted this and, in fact, Campbell goes on to do so himself later, when he describes a rather odd faery girl who calls at a human house near to Kinloch Teagus:
“The stranger was dressed in green, and wore a cap bearing the appearance of the king’s hood of a sheep (currachd an righ caorach). The housewife said the family were at the shielings with the cattle, and there was no food in the house; there was not even a drink of milk. The visitor then asked to be allowed to make brose [porridge] of the dye, and received permission to do what she liked with it. She was asked where she stayed, and she said, ‘in this same neighbourhood.’ She drank off the compost [compote], rushed away, throwing three somersaults, and disappeared.”
Superstitions, 103
This sith lass is remarkable for several reasons: for her gymnastics, her taste for soup made of clothes’ dye- and her hat. The description compares it to the bags made from the second stomach of a sheep; in other words, it appears to be made of leather and is (I’m inferring) quite close-fitting.
Lastly, a few lines from the play Fuimus Troes by Jasper Fisher (1633):
“Fairies small,
Two foot tall,
With caps red
On their head,
Danse around
On the ground.”
Fuimus Troes, act 1 scene 5
Thomas Keightley remarked in his Fairy Mythology (page 342) that this was the earliest mention of this distinctive faery item of clothing that he had found.
So far, so good. On the whole, I think we can say that the faeries were known to wear hats, just like everyone else did, and these were by and large just like everyone else’s- if, perhaps, a little old fashioned, as in the “high crowned hats” being worn by the crowd at the faery market on the Blackdown Hills in Somerset. The colours (red and green) may have been distinctively fae, and a few were a bit fancy, but that was it. Only subsequently, going into the twentieth century, did artists, and (as a result) the public, expect to see something more elaborate and unusual.
I’ve analysed the more modern reports of faery headgear from a variety of sources: Seeing Fairies by Marjorie Johnson, the fairy Census, Janet Bord’s Fairies, and the post-war writings of Conan Doyle and Geoffrey Hodson. This gives us, altogether, nearly five hundred cases to consider. Amongst the cases excluding the Census, hats were worn in about 30% of the encounters. They were typically red or green and over a third of these caps were described as ‘pointed’ or perhaps ‘conical.’ The much more recent Census reported far fewer hat wearing faes (only about 6% of the total) but once again, where headgear was worn, in about a third of cases it was pointy.
What seems to emerge is a perception, or expectation, that faeries will appear dressed in ‘gnome’ hats. As I’ve said, my suspicion is that this is a product of the work of artists like John Anster Fitzgerald, Arthur Rackham and Heath Robinson (see above), and as such has its roots in artistic conventions rather than in folklore.
This isn’t to dismiss hats as fantasy, though. The faeries wore them at a time when this was the norm, but their choice of headwear wasn’t purely utilitarian- just to keep the head warm and dry. As I’ve described before, hats have a much more important, magical function in faery society. Professor John Rhys described the cap that a mermaid needed to live beneath the surface of the sea (Celtic Folklore, vol.1, 118 & 124); Wirt Sikes referred, rather more figuratively I think, to the cap of oblivion or invisibility that fell upon a human taken into a dance within a faery ring (British Goblins, 70 & 83). Nevertheless, such items of headwear are known to British tradition: a story from Annandale in lowland Scotland tells of a man who was invited to a faery wedding. He was given a cap to wear during the wedding feast and found himself surrounded by people dressed in green- until he took the hat off, at which point he was instantly alone in his own barn. Conversely, it’s said in the North Riding of Yorkshire that the faeries have retreated up the dales away from human habitation. They will return from time to time to dance in their old gathering places, but they are never seen unless they take their caps off…
A story from the Ochill Hills describes how the faeries were able to put on a magic cap and then fly through the air; human children holding the faeries’ hands would be able to travel with them. An account from Arisaig, near Lochaber, relates how a cap received by a woman from the local faeries could cure illnesses if worn by the patient. Most intriguingly, Campbell recorded how the water horse of the Scottish Highlands, the each uisge, could be subdued and controlled using either a shackle around its neck or a cap on its head (Superstitions, 204 & 207). Evidently, therefore, magical headgear can be used by faeries and against faeries.
I’ll conclude with three further Scottish examples. The first is from Skye and concerns the deadly power over a man that the possessor of his bonnet may have. The hag known as the Cailleach a’ Chrathaich would steal a man’s bonnet and then wear a hole in it so as to kill him (I’ve mentioned this before in respect of both hags and bauchans). Bonnets, however, could have powers that might be turned against the faeries. In Teviotdale in the Lowlands, there were wise women (called “skilly auld wives’ in the vicinity) who could advise on defences against assaults by the faeries. A mother with her newborn child might, for instance, be protected against abduction by having her husband’s blue bonnet with her at all times. A sickly cow could be cured by striking it with a blue bonnet. The exact significance of it being blue is a mystery to me: although it might be noted that blue was a very rare colour amongst the hats and caps worn by faeries, according to the records.
Lastly, a renowned way of recovering an item or person from the faeries was to throw your bonnet towards them and to declare “This is yours, that’s mine” (‘Is leatsa so, is leamsa sin‘ in Gaelic). If this is done, the faeries have no choice but to make the exchange (see examples in Keightley 392 or Campbell 25). As Campbell says, a knife or mole-hill earth may also be used, but these are all magical substances in the fae universe. The power of the bonnet may have something to do with its wider symbolism of power and authority.